Back to Blog

Fall Arrest vs. Fall Restraint: Understanding Height Safety Systems

When working at heights, safety is paramount. Falls are a leading cause of workplace injuries and fatalities, making it essential for employers and workers to implement effective height safety systems. Two primary systems used for protecting workers at heights are fall arrest and fall restraint. While both are designed to prevent injury during falls, they operate in different ways and are suited to different situations. This blog will explore the key differences between fall arrest and fall restraint systems, helping you make informed decisions about height safety in your workplace.

What is a Fall Arrest System?

A fall arrest system is designed to catch a worker in the event of a fall, preventing them from hitting the ground or a lower level. It doesn’t stop the fall from happening but limits the distance and impact of the fall, reducing the risk of serious injury or death. These systems are critical in situations where workers are exposed to a fall hazard and where eliminating or restraining the fall risk is not possible.

Components of a Fall Arrest System:

1. Anchorage Point: A secure point where the fall arrest system is attached.
2. Body Harness: A full-body harness worn by the worker, distributing the impact of the fall across the body to minimize injury.
3. Lanyard or Lifeline: Connects the harness to the anchor point and includes shock-absorbing elements to reduce the force felt by the worker.
4. Deceleration Devices: Devices like shock absorbers or self-retracting lifelines reduce the fall’s impact force by slowing the worker’s descent.

Fall arrest systems are most commonly used when workers are required to perform tasks at significant heights and cannot be positioned in a way that fully prevents a fall from occurring. However, these systems require specific training, regular inspection, and rescue plans to ensure they work correctly in an emergency.

What is a Fall Restraint System?

Unlike fall arrest systems, fall restraint systems are designed to prevent a fall from happening in the first place. The system restricts the worker’s movement so they cannot reach the edge of a fall hazard. This system is ideal in scenarios where it’s possible to eliminate the risk of falling by limiting how close a worker can get to the edge.

Components of a Fall Restraint System:

1. Anchorage Point: Like fall arrest systems, this is a secure point where the worker’s equipment is attached.
2. Body Harness or Belt: While body harnesses are commonly used, waist belts may also be an option in some restraint systems.
3. Lanyard or Lifeline: A fixed-length lanyard that keeps the worker away from the fall hazard, preventing them from moving into a dangerous area.

Fall restraint systems are typically used in lower-risk environments where workers can be prevented from reaching the fall zone. These systems are often easier to manage, require less equipment, and reduce the need for complex emergency rescue plans since no fall should occur.

Key Differences Between Fall Arrest and Fall Restraint Systems

While both systems aim to protect workers at heights, the main differences between fall arrest and fall restraint lie in how they manage fall risks:

• Prevention vs. Protection: A fall restraint system is preventive, stopping the worker from reaching a fall hazard. In contrast, a fall arrest system is protective, intervening only after a fall has occurred.
• Risk Level: Fall restraint systems are generally used in lower-risk environments where the potential for falling can be completely eliminated by controlling the worker’s movement. Fall arrest systems are necessary in higher-risk situations where workers must be near or on the edge of a fall hazard.
• Complexity of Use: Fall arrest systems require more training, regular inspections, and a rescue plan since a fall is possible. Fall restraint systems, on the other hand, are simpler to implement and maintain.
• Impact on the Worker: A fall arrest system allows a worker to reach a fall hazard, meaning the potential for serious injury exists if the system fails or is used improperly. A fall restraint system, when used correctly, eliminates the possibility of a fall.

When to Use Fall Arrest or Fall Restraint Systems

Choosing between a fall arrest and fall restraint system depends on the specific work environment and the tasks at hand. The goal is always to eliminate or minimize risks wherever possible. Here’s a general guideline for when to use each system:

• Use Fall Arrest Systems when:
• Workers must perform tasks near or at the edge of a fall hazard.
• It is impossible to eliminate or reduce the risk of a fall.
• Rescue procedures are in place, and workers are trained to use fall arrest equipment properly.
• Use Fall Restraint Systems when:
• The work environment allows for controlling worker movement to prevent access to fall hazards.
• The fall risk can be entirely eliminated by using a fixed-length lanyard.
• You want to minimize the complexity of the safety system and reduce the need for emergency rescue plans.

Conclusion

Understanding the difference between fall arrest and fall restraint systems is crucial for ensuring worker safety when working at heights. Fall arrest systems are protective, designed to stop a fall after it occurs, while fall restraint systems are preventive, stopping workers from reaching the fall hazard in the first place. By assessing the specific needs and risks of your workplace, you can choose the appropriate system to safeguard your employees.

Investing in proper height safety systems, training, and equipment inspections not only ensures compliance with safety regulations but also creates a safer work environment for everyone. Always consult with safety professionals to determine the best approach for your particular situation.